Alternative and Mainstream Converge
I spent many happy years working with musicians and their music. I loved it. Some still know me as a former radio guy but there is a much deeper story.
Below The Surface
Radio – like every industry – has much more under the surface than those outside comprehend.
Overseeing a radio station requires regular business stuff like budgets and talent development; promotional duties such as website management and database marketing; and external oversight on such items as advertising and event management.
Turn It Up
As part of my radio career, I worked in what is called the alternative rock format at two stations. Alternative is a distinction that carries as much negative connotation as positive reinforcement.
The core of alternative music fans are rarely happy once a band gains even a modicum of success while those unfamiliar with the genre think it’s full of strange people with purple hair.
It's important to note that both alternative radio stations continue to be successful measured against mainstream metrics. And perhaps with the exception of one year at Hallowe'en, I've never found the need to dye my hair purple. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
I like purple and I digress.
Can you be cutting edge and mainstream at the same time?
In 1988, Michael Trent Reznor formed an industrial rock band called Nine Inch Nails - no doubt you’ve heard of them. Twenty-one years later they have sold millions of albums, CDs and downloads, played in front of massive festival and stadium crowds and won Grammy Awards.
Despite this worldwide success, Nine Inch Nails and Trent Reznor remain categorized as alternative not mainstream.
When NiN formed, there wasn’t the long list of social networking channels we have now. Today, Reznor has over 600,000 followers to his personal Twitter account and his band is well represented through their YouTube and Flickr spaces.
Imagine. Create. Share.
In 2006, Jack Dorsey was looking for something that would kick start a creative slump for his company Odeo. His original idea was to create a conversation space through sms called my.stat.us.
Today, Jack and his partners Biz Stone and Evan Williams, seventy-five employees in a modest San Francisco building and millions in venture capital have grown Twitter to one of the fastest growing web portals in the world with millions of regular users.
From 1975 to 2009, Microsoft has grown from an idea Paul Allen and William Gates had to develop software for the microcomputer to over 90,000 employees in 100 countries and over $58 Billion in annual revenue.
So is Twitter the alternative and Microsoft the mainstream?
Whether you a musician and producer of industrial music, three geeks from Silicon Valley or the world’s largest software manufacturer, you have to start with an idea.
It may be a concept yet to be adopted by anyone else, it could be quite different than the current mainstream thought, but if it’s a good one the audience will discover it.
At that point, will it really matter what label we put on it?
@knealemann
Helping you create your best business,
marketing and social media strategy.
image credit: colourlovers.com

Hey Kneale,
I enjoyed your work in radio - both in Toronto and Ottawa - and I now enjoy your blog. Keep it up, this was another great post.
Ken said... November 2, 2009 4:31 PM
I've always strugged with the 'alternative' handle but it's more of an attitude thing for me. Even if Twitter made $58B a year but remained true to the original concept I'd stil call it 'alternative'. Of course, the chances of that happening are remote.
Still love NiN too!
Lydia said... November 2, 2009 4:33 PM
What a great concept, cool!
Sadly, NiN is mainstream but with an alternative heart.
Brianne said... November 2, 2009 4:35 PM
Great post, Kneale... I love how you tie this convergence to the growth of Twitter and Microsoft. You make an interesting point about how we shouldn't overlook the unique cultural value sets that even those most popularized platforms can create.
Good stuff!
Gunther Sonnenfeld said... November 2, 2009 8:19 PM
I had to read this blog entry twice which I think is the point. I have a client I need to show this to and thanks for sharing it.
Stan said... November 2, 2009 10:47 PM
I think that's a picture of my sister circa 1987! Kidding.
You tie these concepts together well, thanks it makes a lot of sense now.
Sally said... November 3, 2009 8:07 AM
Thanks very much Ken, that's very kind of you sir. I'm glad you enjoyed the post. Cheers km
Kneale Mann said... November 3, 2009 8:08 AM
Lydia, that's always the struggle. I chose to use "mainstream" and "alternative" but I could have just as easily used "start-up" and "established".
You're right, it's all about the attitude. km
Kneale Mann said... November 3, 2009 8:08 AM
Agreed, Brianne!
Kneale Mann said... November 3, 2009 8:09 AM
Thanks Gunther, that means a lot. It's funny how often we see eye to eye on concepts.
Lovin' your blog - keep writing!
www.welcometonow.blogspot.com
Kneale Mann said... November 3, 2009 8:10 AM
Stan, that's outstanding news. Please keep me posted! km
Kneale Mann said... November 3, 2009 8:10 AM
Hey Sally,
I think any of us who were 'around' in the '80s have pictures from our past we'd rather not see surface. But the alternative attitude remains! km
Kneale Mann said... November 3, 2009 8:11 AM
I like it!
James said... November 3, 2009 8:13 AM
Is it me or can you not still have an alternaive sensibility while being successful? Yeah, thought so.
Jack said... November 3, 2009 8:14 AM
great post as always my friend!
Beth Warren said... November 3, 2009 10:08 AM
Awesome read. Seriously, take the time RT @knealemann: New Post: A story about Trent Reznor, Bill Gates and Twitter. http://bit.ly/UHFbW
Chelsea said... November 3, 2009 11:42 AM
Interesting you chose MSFT and not GOOG for the 'mainstream'. I would argue MSFT is nowhere online, and are v. unprofitable. When I think about search, I think Google, and my alternative is not Bing, but twitter (I know it sounds odd, but true). IMHO Twitter is 'alternative' to Facebook's 'mainstream'
Adrian said... November 3, 2009 7:53 PM
Post a Comment